Vault

Max value reached

Adding this item would put you over your total vault limit of $250. please review your cart to stay under the limit.

Have you ever 'faked' a product?

2 August, 2015 - 09:14pm by - First Lady | 36 Comments

Poll posted by BR Natalie

If there's one thing our Save or Splurge feature proves - it's that there is most definitely elitism within our treasured industry.

Let's say the average lipstick costs around $20.  Well head into the local Dollar Store and you can probably find a pretty decent Jordana lipstick for a couple of dollars.  And of course you could head to you local MAC counter, or even local NZ company and pick up a lipstick for $40.  And if your budget stretches even further, well you could pay upwards of $80 for something like the nifty Guerlain lipstick.

But how much weight do we put on brand names?  And does brand importance encourage us to fake it?

Here's just some of the ways one could 'fake' a beauty product.

  • If someone asked the brand of your lipstick, would you proudly say "Jordana", would you 'forget' where you bought it from, or would you outright lie and say "Karen Murrell"?
  • Have you ever knowingly bought a fake product, just so you could say you owned Mac?  Or Chanel?  Or Dior?
  • Have you ever depotted a product into the empty of a more expensive product?

Oh yes, the Beauty Confessional is once again open, and we want to know...have you ever faked a beauty product?

And if you're feeling brave - tell us what and how below!

Have you ever 'faked' a product?


View results

View previous polls

Comments

Please sign in or register to add a comment.

2nd August, 2015

I havent faked a product. Although it would be cool to say its a "this" or "that" I dont mind saying exactly what it is. I am what I am and it is what it is.

2nd August, 2015

If I like it I'll wear it. I'm not a brandie, I have a chi chi lipstick that's a dupe for a more expensive Mac Lipstick and if someone were to ask I'll tell them it's chi chi, not Mac. I like the color and so I wear it. However I have been buying some higher end brands of late. Not because I need everything high end but because I like the shade and so I determine I need it. I currently have Lime Crime, Karen Murrell and Mac Lipsticks and even a Marc Jacobs lip gloss but at the same time I have some cheapies in my makeup bag that I wear just the same.

2nd August, 2015

The only thing I fake is my hair colour;)

2nd August, 2015

I didn't even know what was meant by "have you ever faked a product". I'm always happy to share the details of the item if asked whether it cost me a dollar or a dollar multiplied by an "evil number".

I also don't see anything wrong with depotting product into expensive compacts/palettes - they cost a bomb may as well make good use of it. I couldn't care less if they told me it's Chanel when really it's L'Oreal - to each their own.

2nd August, 2015

Can't say that I have. I'm not really into elitism and love finding a bargain. As long as it is quality of a certain standard and it doesn't irritate my skin then it's all good. I can't imagine why people need to fake it?

2nd August, 2015

I have never faked a product! I would be much prouder to say that I have a Jordana lipstick if someone commented than MAC. That would be like saying I am so awesome at finding makeup that I found this awesome cheap one :) I have kept packaging even when empty. I have a Dior lip balm container that I'm keeping to keep my stud earrings in because the packaging is so nice.

Koni
2nd August, 2015

Absolutely agree with you Kirsty!

Kellyleanne
2nd August, 2015

I feel the same way Kirsty.

chloednz
2nd August, 2015

Totally- that's how I feel! Just shows what a great bargain hunter you are that you got a great product for a great price!

trudijoy
2nd August, 2015

100% agree

Charmmy-Kitty
2nd August, 2015

Agreed! I mean I'm awesome enough to find a cheap product that works amazingly and I have to be proud of that!

Jesse
2nd August, 2015

Well said!

_Nicole_
3rd August, 2015

Definatly with you on this one. It's far more impressive that your able to pull of an amazing look like a cheep product

MAGPIEFI
4th August, 2015

i feel the same Kirsty, well said x

tannygirl
3rd August, 2015

It is also largely due to the fact that I have decided to go for bold lip shades, I have decided to spend a bit more on brands that have good reviews on their lippies to be long wear.

Macs
2nd August, 2015

Ditto, Im exactly the same when it comes to products.

WELCOME TO NZ'S BIGGEST BEAUTY GUIDE!

READ AND WRITE REVIEWS ON YOUR FAVOURITE (or not so favourite!) PRODUCTS!

Sign up to receive our newsletter and stay up to date with all of the latest happenings here at Beauty Review!

You'll be the first to know about Trial Teams, Vault restocks and Giveaways.

We promise never to spam you - only to share the best in NZ beauty!

CLICK HERE TO JOIN THE MAILING LIST!