Vault

Max value reached

Adding this item would put you over your total vault limit of $250. please review your cart to stay under the limit.

MAC Mystery Shopper Exposé

5 May, 2014 - 06:00am by - BR-Queenie | 38 Comments

Ballantynes MAC Counter

Article by BR Merilyn

In the first of our Mystery Shopping series we sent SuperHero Ellie off to the MAC Counter at  Ballantynes in Christchurch.

Her mission was to book herself a make-up consultation and armed with $120, purchase products recommended for her by her consultant.  MAC counters offer “free” make up consultations or make up sessions where you can meet with a consultant for an hour, get a new look if you feel your make up needs refreshing or, get your makeup done for a special occasion.  It costs $90, which is redeemable on product to the same value when your consultation is finished.

So, how did Ellie get on? Did it live up to its hype? And would she go back? Let’s find out!

BR: What was the assignment you were given?

ES: Tough gig! I needed to book myself in for a make up consultation at MAC, and then purchase products recommended for my by the consultant I saw.

BR: Describe your first impressions when you walked into the store?

ES: The appointment was easy to get. I rang up and the person who answered was friendly and helpful. She asked me what day would suit and then what time of day and I was able to get an appointment that suited me well. When I walked into Ballentynes I went over to the MAC counter and was greeted almost straight away and told them I had an appointment. They already knew my name and introduced themselves to me straight away. I felt very welcomed and comfortable which was great! The parking was fine as we have a lot of parking in the centre city in Christchurch. The two staff working at MAC when I went both seemed very friendly and approachable. 

BR: What was the name of your consultant?

Junee

BR: What questions did she ask you before commencing your consultation?

ES: What makeup look I was going for, what my skin type is at the moment, what kind of coverage I was after, what type of finish I wanted in a foundation, and if this was my normal skin colour in the winter.

BR: What information did you give her?

ES: A neutral everyday look, oily/combo skin, medium coverage, dewy finish, and this is my normal winter skin colour

BR: Describe what happened during your consultation. Talk about the environment, how you felt during the appointment, your consultant’s attitude towards you, her recommendations etc

ES: The environment was calm and relaxing. The music was a nice volume and wasn't too loud. Junee was absolutely lovely and made conversation with me but didn't force it. She also complimented my various facial features throughout the consultation, which was really nice! She had a very professional approach to the consultation but she was still friendly and not too serious. The other makeup artist who was working was also really lovely and complimented me at points too which is always a bonus!

BR: How experienced/professional did you think they were?

ES: Very experienced and professional. She was very fast but incredibly thorough at the same time and knew exactly what she was doing. She explained the whole process.

BR: What did you like about your experience?

ES: Both of the makeup artists were lovely people. I wasn't pressured to buy anything and Junee was very helpful in letting me know the price of things. I really liked that she explained every single product and every single step because it meant that I actually learned from the consultation! I am very, very happy with my experience - it took about an hour but the time completely flew by as I was so relaxed. I also really liked that I was given a face chart at the end which showed where to apply each product, and an entire product list with every product she used in each of the particular shades/colours. She even wrote down what brushes she used for each thing, which is also very helpful.

BR: Anything you didn’t like?

ES: I thought it was a little odd that they make you pay the $90 for the consultation via credit card over the phone when you book - the person I spoke to on the phone said they couldn't book you in otherwise. While I understand that they do this to ensure that your appointment is secured, it would be terrible to have something happen at the last minute and not be able to get to your consultation, which you had already paid for! 

BR: Were you happy with the outcome from your experience?

ES: I was really, really happy with the way I was treated and the way my face looked afterwards. Junee gave me a look that was exactly what I asked for and she made me feel beautiful which is pretty much the point. I was also happy with the products I walked away with because I got to choose them myself and wasn't pressured into buying anything in particular. 

BR: Would you visit this place again, if you were paying for it yourself?

ES: Yes. I've never been to a makeup counter prior to today and this has encouraged me to do it again. I hadn't done it before because I was too scared of being judged but I did not feel judged at all.

BR: Would you recommend this experience to a friend?

ES: Yes! I actually went out shopping with a friend afterwards and recommended it to her straight away.

BR: What products did you buy with your spending money?

ES: Mineralize Lipstick in 'Good Taste' and Mineralize Moisture SPF15 Foundation in NC20

BR: Is there anything else would you like to add?

ES: I think I have pretty much covered it all. Overall I think I had a great experience. The makeup artists were professional, friendly and knew exactly what they were doing. I'd never tried MAC prior to today but I know for sure that I will be going back thanks to today's experience!

 

The gorgeous Ellie with her post MAC look

Update: 4 days later…Ellie confesses on twitter that she’s already been shopping at MAC online…

Footnote:

Ellie’s Mystery Shop consultation was at the MAC Counter in Ballantynes, Christchurch. She went completely independently and her views are her own based on her experience. This mystery shop is not commissioned nor sponsored by MAC in any way.

 

 

 

 

 

back

Comments

Please sign in or register to add a comment.

29th September, 2015

ahh people were referencing this today and i had to search it out. Very cool, ellie x

4th July, 2014

I love that they MUA used a bright pink lippy for a natural/every day look instead of the standard neutrals and browns. It really suits Ellie, and just brings the whole look to life.

18th May, 2014

I've been a long-time fan of MAC, and your post MAC look is gorgeous!

16th May, 2014

Wow, sounds like a fun experience. I might have to work up the courage to go to a makeup counter myself! You look great :)

10th May, 2014

I love your look they created!! I am glad you had fun :) it's a tough job and someone had to do it - hahahaha awesome work!!

8th May, 2014

Wow, that would have been fun! The Mac team at Kirkaldies and Stains always seem busy and a fun looking professional team too...

7th May, 2014

That's awesome and I really love the lip colour!

7th May, 2014

This is great. I've always been a bit shy about having a consultation but it sounds like a fantastic experience. I recently booked a facial at an Estée Lauder counter but in the end I couldn't make the appointment. They happily refunded my booking fee, which I actually ended up spending on product anyway, so a win-win for both of us.

7th May, 2014

Fantastic review! And what a great idea from you guys BR! So helpful!

7th May, 2014

What an awesome assignment! Your make up looks flawless! Next time I have $90 to spend on make up (which doesn't happen very often!!) I think I might have to look at booking in! I don't own any MAC but always hear fantastic reviews. I think its great you get to spend the $90 on cosmetics after your consultation, don't think I could justify $90 on just a consultation otherwise! haha

7th May, 2014

A friend took me to that exact counter as a "false lash virgin" and i too had an amazing experience!! i live in Auckland now and have yet to do a full make up consult at MAC - after reading this article i think i will book in a consult for my next event! thanks Ellie and thanks BR!

7th May, 2014

What a great read! Sounds like you had the best time and you look absolutely amazing in your picture! <3

7th May, 2014

What a good read, Ellie! I feel like I was almost there with you, and in saying that, man, I want to book myself over the road at Kirkcaldies!

7th May, 2014

Consultations are definitely a great way to learn how to apply make-up properly and what colors/shades compliment your face! I always try to tie my consultations in with an event i.e. booking one in before attending a wedding to learn how to achieve a great look for special occasions and get my make-up done professionally for the event - bonus! Being able to redeem the cost on products is also a huge bonus! I haven't been to MAC and I don't currently use their makeup - but I may have to try them for my next consultation. I especially like that they informed Ellie of what brushes to use - this ALWAYS puzzles me!

7th May, 2014

I have done this once before myself and found it a great experience. Helps to build your confidence in using a wider variety of products.

WELCOME TO NZ'S BIGGEST BEAUTY GUIDE!

READ AND WRITE REVIEWS ON YOUR FAVOURITE (or not so favourite!) PRODUCTS!

Sign up to receive our newsletter and stay up to date with all of the latest happenings here at Beauty Review!

You'll be the first to know about Trial Teams, Vault restocks and Giveaways.

We promise never to spam you - only to share the best in NZ beauty!

CLICK HERE TO JOIN THE MAILING LIST!