157,328reviews

11,353products

New Zealand's biggest beauty guide

No query specified.

HOME
BRAND DIRECTORY
SKIN CARE
Search by category:
- Baby Care
- Best Beauty Box Ever
- Body Care
  Bath & Shower Care
  
  Exfoliators
  
  Moisturisers
  
  Natural
  
  Sunscreens
  
  Tanning
  
  Treatments
- Facial Skincare
  Age-defying
  
  Cleansers
  
  Exfoliators
  
  Eye care
  
  Face Masks
  
  Lip Balms
  
  Lip Scrubs
  
  Makeup Removers
  
  Moisturisers
  
  Natural
  
  Regimes
  
  Serums & Treatments
  
  Sunscreen
  
  Tanning
  
  Toner
  
  Young Skin
- Feet
  Moisturisers
  
  Tools
  
  Treatments
- Hands
  Hand Cream
  
  Hand Sanitisers
  
  Hand Wash
  
  Treatment
- Multi Purpose
- NZ Brands
  Body
  
  Face
  
  Feet
  
  Hands
  
  Multi Purpose
- Oils
COSMETICS
Search by category:
- Brushes & Tools
  Eye Lash Curlers
  
  Make Up Brushes
  
  Sponges
  
  Tweezers
- Eyes
  Brow care
  
  Eye Pencils
  
  Eyeliners
  
  Eyeshadows
  
  False Eyelashes
  
  Lash Serums
  
  Mascaras
- Foundations & Bases
  BB Cream
  
  Blusher
  
  Bronzer
  
  Concealer
  
  Contouring
  
  Foundation
  
  Highlighter
  
  Powder
  
  Primer
  
  Setting Spray
- Lips
  Lip Liner
  
  Lip Tints
  
  Lip glosses
  
  Lipsticks
- NZ Brands
- Nails
  Nail Polish Removers
  
  Nail Polishes
  
  Tools
  
  Top & Base Coats
  
  Treatments
HAIR CARE
Search by category:
- Hair Colour
  Permanent
  
  Temporary
- Hair Styling
  Accessories
  
  Products
  
  Tools
- Hair Treatments
- Regimes
- Shampoo & Conditioner
  Dry
  
  Liquid
  
  Solid
FRAGRANCE
Search by category:
PERSONAL CARE
Search by category:
MEN'S
Search by category:

Top 10 eyeliners as reviewed by you!

6 April, 2015 - 10:26am by - First Lady | 33 Comments

Article by BR Natalie

The beauty skill most people want to master is eyeliner - and of course to start you need to find a great eyeliner product. Luckily we know where to find out which products are worth parting with your hard earned cash!

So here's a list of the top ten eyeliners in New Zealand; and this is a list with a difference - it's been dictated by our members, because you are our experts on beauty products!

1 - Za Liquid Eyeliner - Average rating: 4.8/5

2 - Natio Mechanical Long Lasting Eyeliner - Average rating: 4.6/5

3 - Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner - Average rating: 4.6/5

4 - Exaggerate Liquid - Average rating: 4.4/5

5 - Stila Liquid Eyeliner - Average rating: 4.3/5

6 - Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner - Average rating: 4.1/5

7 - Eye of Horus Liquid Define Liner - Average rating: 4.1/5

8 - Avon Glimmersticks Eye Liner - Average rating: 4.1/5

9 - Maybelline Eye Studio Gel Eyeliner - Average rating: 4.1/5

10 - e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner - Average rating: 3.7/5

So there you have it - The Top Ten Eyeliners in New Zealand, as rated by you . Did your favourite make the list? Or did you find one you need to try?

*All products have a minimum of 10 reviews submitted against them. List doesn't include kohls or eye crayons.

Comments

Please sign in or register to add a comment.

MrsO

8th May, 2015

I am going to get the Za one, sounds great.

PJ73

17th April, 2015

Although I admit to using several of these top 10s my go to is Napoleon Perdis Matte Eye Ink. It is super fine and budge free all day but best of all I find it really easy to apply evenly to both eyes. And it is paraben free. My previous go to was Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner but I am really keen to try the Za brand now as it seems to have so many great reviews.

Danni

13th April, 2015

I had the Rimmel exaggerate when I was starting out and struggled so I may have to pick it up again now that I'm a bit more experienced! However my all time favourite is hyperglossy which isn't on there!

Kimrose

10th April, 2015

I tried my Za eyeliner this morning for the first time and I was happy...I went really lightly because it was the first time ever I had used an eyeliner. I will go a bit darker when I dont have to work.

ree_nz

10th April, 2015

I really want to try Eye of Horus products! Have heard good things.

bevik1971

10th April, 2015

I've been using Avon eyeliners for years, I love them - great colours and go on really well plus long lasting. I do also have the Maybelline Eye Studio gel liner which I love. I do have a pen liner from Australia at home They're Real Push up liner which I have only been game to try once and didn't do a very good job of applying lol so I'll have to give it another go :)

MissQT

9th April, 2015

I've never heard of the exaggerate liner, that's a new brand to me.

janini9

9th April, 2015

Just tried the Za eyeliner from the Beauty Box. Wow! It is fantastic, I can draw such a thin even line. Maybe I can do eyeliner after all.

k3r1pakai

8th April, 2015

Well looks like ZA came top of the ratings. I must say it is the more affordable product with great quality. It's not the pen liner that's the problem though its my shaky lids lol that just can't perfect the look.

MareeB

8th April, 2015

I've been using liquid eyeliner for 40 odd years and find it great. I haven't tried the Za liquid eyeliner yet but am keen to see if it's as good as everyone says.

peanuts579

8th April, 2015

I've think I've only tried the Maybelline Eye Studio Gel Eyeliner, but wasn't the best at applying it so I stopped using it. Maybe I'll have to give it another go. I prefer using the felt tip eyeliners but I have only been regularly using eyeliner for the past few months as I was so terrible at and still am. I'll just have to keep on practicing :)

Kellyleanne

8th April, 2015

Great to know, now I have the top ones on my wishlist!

Shazzaali

8th April, 2015

Thanks for that. I'm always on the look out for new liquid eyeliners

nemesisroxx

7th April, 2015

I loooove the Stila Liner, I was recently gifted it by a friend and it's so amazing, I don't normally favour pen liners! Haven't tried the Za one yet.. I also love the Maybelline gel liner for certain looks. I really love the Avon Liquid Liner above all!!!