I currently own two of these shadows. I say currently because I had close to 20 of them last year when I had gotten caught in the hype of them but then I quickly realised that I really dislike these!
I have the shades Lectra which is a metallic purple and Onai which is a pink satin shade. These are both really pretty colours. The purple is intense and Onai is a perfect inner corner highlight shade, brightening but not so in your face that it looks crazy.
These come packaged separately in little white screw top jars. I think the packaging is not appealing. I think it's the white, I did used to have their special birthday shade which came in a pink tub and I thought that looked really cute. Even black or pretty much any other colour would look better. Or even mattes, glitters and metallics to reflect on the colours within? Anyway, the reason these come in their own container is because these have a unique cream texture that would dry out if it was in a normal palette. I personally prefer palettes over singles but I understand the reasoning behind this packaging.
Now, something I don't see a lot of people talk about is that these only have a shelf life of around a year before they will dry out. Even the ones I have are less than a year old and are always screwed tightly shut but they have lost the nice mousse texture and are quite hard to the touch now but are still just usable.
This short shelf life was part of the reason why I got rid of most of mine. The other big reason is I just find them hard to use. They are best applied with your finger but obviously you can't be too accurate like that and I don't find they blend well with a brush. Yes, these have incredible pigmentation and any swatches look beautiful but to me that means nothing if it's harder to work with on your eyes. These also crease badly on me. The lasting power is reasonable, they don't fade straight away but it won't last all day.
The reason I kept these two is because purple is my favourite colour for eyeshadow, not that I reach for this often! And the other one I had pushed my brush in to see how far down it went in the jar (not very far, these are quite shallow pans). I do use this one pretty much everyday, not because it's a holy grail but because I'd like to use as much of it up as I can before it completely dries up.
Another downside is cost. Yes these are only $5 each but that's US, the shipping prices are horrendous as well.
I would never buy these again and I just couldn't recommend them to anyone.
OMG I love this product. From the moment I opened the box I was impressed. You could really see that they took care of the product by protecting it so well and the box was so cool (you can turn it inside-out and use it as a decorative box)... stepping aside from the impressive postage, I was doubly pleased with the product.
Pros: - Amazing pigmentation - Great variety of colours - Love the putty texture
Cons: - Not for people who love to work with pallets, the separate cases can take up a lot of space. - You can get the best results using your fingers, however, my fingers are too un-co and I've yet to master the art of blending the product properly, so it can be difficult to sometimes use the product. - Product is stated to only have a shelf life of 1 year before it dries out