I bought this palette a while ago off Beautylish. Unfortunately they no longer stock this brand! I have the original choc bar palette so while I didn't need this at all, I just really wanted it. I see this on heaps of youtube tutorials and I was just so drawn to it.
First, lets talk about the packaging. It's in a metal tin and it's shaped like a chocolate bar. How could you not love that?? Sometimes, I think Too Faced go a bit overboard on cutesy packaging but I think this is just nice to look at without feeling like play makeup from the $2 shop. This is a slightly lighter brown then the original palette so even though it matches, you can tell the difference without having to open them both up. The magnetic clasp is strong and I don't feel like it's going to let me down and ruin these precious shadows. When you open it, you see a small mirror, and of course the eyshadows. I love that the names are printed on the packaging, the original doesn't have that and it annoys me a lot!
These shadows are such a beautiful mix of neutrals with a blue pop too. You get a lot of mattes plus some shimmer and glitter too. There are dark shades and light shades and enough variety to create a multitude of different looks. Also unless you have been living under a rock, then you'll know these smell delicious. They are infused with cocoa powder and you can smell it too. These shadows are excellent quality, very pigmented and easy to blend. Too faced mattes are such a great formula, they are not chalky at all. My favourite shades are Rum Raisin- a gorgeous shimmery taupe, peanut butter - a perfect warm, peachy transition shade and caramel which is a bronzed amber shade. The black in this palette is one of the most intense blacks I have ever used, you only need the tiniest amount ever! Coconut Crème is the perfect matte slightly yellow base shade or to blend things out. I do wish there was a champagne shimmer for inner corner highlighting. The butter pecan shade is too orange for my liking. Otherwise I feel like this works so well. It definitely has more cooler tones but there is some warmth in there too.
These last well on my lids. I do get creasing if I don't use a primer but I get that from every shadow. I have slightly hooded oily lids so shadow won't normally last long on me.
You definitely wouldn't feel let down by quality if you bought this palette. Do I think you need both choc palettes though? No, not really. I reckon if you like more warm tones, go with the original and if you like more cool tones, go with this one. While I adore my fave shades, I don't think that any of the browns of which there is 6 in here, are anything unique. I'm sure you would have dupes of these in other palettes already.
I don’t have the original chocolate palette, so I can’t compare, I got this one as I liked the look of the colours a bit better, especially the blue shade.
Packaging is so beautiful and sturdy, the palette just looks amazing and I really like the sweet chocolate scent too, although not sure of the purpose, but I guess it’s good as a novelty.
The quality of the shadows are really good, these are blending better than some of my urban decay naked palettes, pigmentation is just perfect, not too much, but can build it up.
The colours are really nice too, however some browns look the same on the eyelids, like they’re just not different enough to create that many looks. I see this problem in a lot of their palette’s though. Basically if I run out of one brown shade I just have a backup in the same palette, is the way I see this. And I don’t mind it too much really. I could create all the looks I’ve had in mind, so some “double-up” shades aren’t the end of the world.