Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Review

I've used this product for near 10 years. I love the saturation of colour, the ease of application and the fact that it's self sharpening (ie winds up and down). One low point is the fact that it can break easily and pieces can fall out once the lead breaks.

Another low point is that I don't think it lasts for 16 hours. I'm prone to watery eyes so I found it does smudge and wear off by the end of the workday and needs re-application.

I love this eyeliner! It is so dark and pigmented and it doesn,t smudge on my water line at all. It has become an absolute essential in my makeup kit and I love to use when I need a long lasting liner. Definitely recommend to everyone.

Since it's called Colorstay I thought it might actually stay but after a 9 hour day at work (my standard everyday hours) I couldn't find a trace of it on my face.. At least I can say it wasn't smudged or anything but that's because it wasn't there at all! In saying that, it was easy and good to apply, very coloured and after trying it with a eyelid primer too, it stayed on all day easily but I don't always have time to do this so it isn't an everyday use product for me.

Smooth and easy to apply. Nice quality product. My only complaint is that is seems to disappear to fast which make me feel its not value for money.

Love that this has a twist up mechanism so there's never any sharpening required. The black is well and truly black, and it lasts well even in the waterline.

I've brought this in black twice now and also in copper.

I really like the twist up pencil and the formula of it, the pencil glides on really smooth. I find I don't personally need to sharpen it but having the sharpener on the end is still a great idea.

I also LOVE that they come with a smudger (cannot think of correct name?!) Although this can be a little harsh on the eyelid if pressed to hard, if gentle enough it does blend nicely.

The eyeliner lasted all day at work for me and found no trouble removing it, maybe just a little more time was needed to make sure it was all gone.

The only downside I faced with this product because I switched and swapped my eyeliners I didnt use these ones daily and therefore they went a little dry on me, which made them more difficult to apply and not getting the results I desired.

I would defiantly purchase this again and would make sure I stuck to using them more to get my monies worth!

I'm using the dark purple which I found at a Big bucket sale. It is a soft but not gel - soft pencil so it's good for a smokey eye look. It doesn't dry immediately so I can smudge it a little, and then it stays in place. It would be good if it came with its own smudger like the Rimmel eyeliners do. The purple is almost black so I like it when trying to create a softer look with pinks greys or purple shadows, it's more complimentary than a harsh dark black.

Brand says colour stay that true.eyeliner is very long lasting and no need any sharping or anything like that,very handy these all good side of it. Now back to reality not creamy and smooth for dry eyelid bc I have dry eyelid it's horrible and another thing you need good cleanser to remove it otherwise you have to rub it. Never buy it again bc there is heaps of pretty eyeliner out there and cheap too

This is amazing, it stays on for a long time and it's waterproof! Although it does tend to smudge in the heat.