I purchased this at Pricewise in Ponsonby, Auckland because I really love thicker pen-type liquid eyeliners. I was really excited when I tried it the first time. BUT...
An hour into wear, I found that it smudged PROFUSELY on my eyelid. I should mention that I have hooded eyes, and the superior part of my lid does fold down over the space between my eyelid which makes something waterproof/smudge proof very important, and it just transferred like MAD. In addition, the instructions do say that it's "not suitable for contact lens wearers" which I'm not sure why that is, which makes it not ideal for everybody.
Was just generally disappointed. So I gave it to someone else who doesn't have the same eyeshape as me, and hope that they do well with it.
This is the perfect liquid liner pen - its really easy to draw a very precise line, especially if you want a winged look. I also found it lasted quite a while and did not rub off too easily. Its perfect for a polished, evening look.
Tips: Apply on top of power eyeshadow - it gives a darker, smoother line when wearing eyeshadow than an eye pencil does.