I'm on the fence with this eyeliner, on the one hand, it does give the blackest line that stays fast, but on the other, it moves around on first application that you end up with the zebra type stripe on your lower waterline. Tried to top it up but then it just drags and just looks clumpy and overdrawn.
On the lid and under the upper lash line it holds super fast and has a great creamy texture that allows you to easily glide it into place and holds a rather pointy sharp tip even though it is creamy which makes application great.
I just can not get over the moving on the water line to make me want to re-use or repurchase.
i got this a while ago but recently sharpened it back up and got to work. it sharpened nicely and to a soft point.
it goes on easily and doesnt smudge... for about 5 minutes. i noticed it on the way to town that it had already smudged and it was giving me panda eyes. not impressed.
doesnt pull the skin, like it literally glides on. but the smudging i cant get past unfortunately.