BYS Waterproof Eyeliner

I bought this eyeliner by mistake, picked the wrong one up but thought I might as well give it a go as it was only $6. I had never used a liquid eyeliner before but was told by a friend that liquid is better as they are waterproof and last longer. I found the eyeliner hard to apply, the brush was quite awkward to hold on to. I did like the colour though, it was a nice black and stayed on well. Just took awhile to dry. Ok for my first eyeliner to practice with.

Do not buy this eyeliner. It's watery and the applicator isn't even a brush it's some kind of hard plastic. The liner chips off and the colour isn't that strong. An eyeliner that I got in a super cheap makeup kit from Kmart was much better than this eyeliner and the whole kit probably cost as much as the eyeliner did. This is an awful eyeliner and I complained but they didn't really do much. Do not buy.

The eyeliner stayed on, it lasted for a few hours, and the color was a strong black. However, I prefer my brushes like paint brushes, and I found this one too stiff for my liking.

This is cheap as chips and does a great job. It is very black which is great, not watery at all. The only downside for me is that it can occasionally crack after a few hours wear.

Love this product, use it all the time. Occasionally it does crack a little in hot environments. Otherwise its great. Nice and dark. Love the applicator tip nice and small

The price and colour are great however I'm not a fan of stiff applicator tips and I had cracking within a couple of hours which is a huge put off for me.

This little bottle looks like it would do the trick, but boy was I wrong.

The applicator is absolutely useless. It is way too stiff which makes it very difficult to apply - and I am no newbie to liquid eyeliner. Have been rocking the cat eye for 6 years now!

The actual formula is no good either. It rubs off in a couple of hours and goes flaky.

I like this eyeliner, although I find it smudges very easily. However I love the colour and the brush :)

I liked the darkness of the black with this eyeliner but I didn't really like the brush. For me it made it quite hard to apply (although I'm not incredible at applying eyeliner so it could just be me haha) I wore it to a party and after an hour or two it started flaking off and looking unfinished and just bad in general. It says that it is smudge proof but for me it didn't seem that way at all because when it flakes (after an hour or two) It tends to travel elsewhere on your face which leaves marks. I wouldn't recommend this to a friend and I would look for a different brand for liquid eyeliner. I have changed to gel eyeliner now and love it but if I wanted to try a liquid one again I would look for something else.

The packaging of this reminds me a lot of Revlon's Colourstay Liquid Liner. I like the packaging - it looks sleek and sophisticated.

I also like the brush that comes with this as I found it really easy to apply and it can create a nice sharp, fine line.

The pigmentation of the liner is fairly decent - I didn't find myself having to trace over any lines in order to darken it, which I really liked.

However - the formula of this is absolute rubbish. Within 3-4 hours of wearing it, it literally started flaking off of my lids. I didn't have anything with me at work to fill it in so I ended up removing it all as it was embarassing walking around with patchy liner on my lids.

Although I didn't find it to smudge or bleed, I wouldn't ever recommend this or use it again just because it literally cracked and fell off of my eyelids. I wore this 3 times with 2 different primers and it always cracked and flaked off. I threw it in the bin.