I got this from one of my beauty subscription boxes. I stopped wearing eyeliner when I was 17, and when I received this. I thought I'll try applying eyeliner again.
I apply them to my waterline and they run smooth and very pigmented. However, they do smudge and ruins the make up for the day. This product is not for me.
Bought this in gold because it was on sale ($1!) and I thought why not. But applying it isn't creamy at all, it feels more like a colouring pencil. Wasn't very happy with the overall finish either, again it looked more like what you would get from a colouring pencil. Haven't wanted to use it since the first time I tried it so probably wasn't even worth the $1.