I got this recently from a makeup sale for $10 and love it! I don't wear mascara that often but when I do this is just perfect.
The wand is medium sized which makes it really easy to apply. I apply 2 coats and wowza, my quite short lashes are transformed into those of a goddess! They become really long, curved and gorgeously dark.
I have had no issues with clumps or smudging and find it reasonably easy to remove with makeup remover wipes.
The yellow and purple packaging is really cute and is actually what stood out for me at the sale. Highly recommend!
I have the black waterproof version of this mascara and when i first put it on i really thought it was nice, it made my lashes look amaziging and gave them lots of volume. But after wearing this for an hour i noticed the black under my eyes, it dosnt last long and smudged under my eyes really badly. Through out the whole day i seemed to have more mascara under my eyes than on my actual lashes. This could just be the water proof one but i wouldn't use this product again. Definitely preferred the falsies by maybelline