I have this in the shade Caramel which is a beautiful, neutral-toned medium brown. After using this for a while my verdict is: Meh, it's okay.
The positives: The formula is very creamy and smooth. I find that the colour lasts well and survives through a full day of work plus a cardio workout without smudging. I love that the spoolie on the end has its own cap which keeps it nice and clean and better to travel with.
The negatives: The problem I found with this product is that it's only good if you want a really soft looking brow. If you want defined edges, hair-like brush strokes or sharp lines you're out of luck as the tip of the gel pencil gets very rounded after the first use. The formula is not the easiest to blend out if you accidentally overdo it and end up depositing too much colour in one spot. This is the kind of gel pencil that will run out quickly. I will use the whole thing up but will most likely not repurchase (but I'll definitely keep the spoolie!)
Use it if: you want natural but full-looking brows. I wear it to work when I want a softer look.
Don't use it if: you want sharp, well defined brows.
Great tapered angled definer. I loved using the Mellow Brow Definer as I found the angled head made the product easy to apply. It covers a large area of brow at a time so you only need to be light when applying and not press too hard. It was super creamy, (I find with a lot of creamy products they slip through the day BUT NOT THIS ONE!) I did find it difficult getting a sharp crisp edge with this product however when trying it with a thinner tip pencil on the outline the definer looked stunning. The twisting function for extra product is a great idea as you don’t use too much and you don’t need a sharpener! The spoolie on the opposite end makes it easy to give a more natural look and helps blend the product through from tip to end.
Tips: Found brows look fuller and more even when spoolie was used both before and after application