I have 4 of these and overall I love them. Whitsunday is my favourite, it's a beautiful shimmering sky blue with great colour payoff. I also have Palm, Sunrise, and Sunset. Great colour payoff for all of these. Applying with a finger can give more colour payoff too. I love that they are natural. Occasionally application can be a bit patchy, I notice this mainly with Sunset. Not sure if it's a different formula or if it is just because it is so dark and I only want a small amount. It just doesn't blend out nicely so I have to be careful when I apply it.
Overall I love these but I do think that the quality varies between colours. Palm and Whitsunday seem creamier, although they are my newest ones so perhaps the formula has changed. I would try other colours but I think the best thing to do is look at the texture of a sample in store before you buy. Happy with my purchase :)
I love how this eyeshadow is natural and very smooth to apply. The shades are very beautiful but I wish they were more pigmented. When applied with an eyeshadow brush you need to use a lot to get a proper colour, which also leads to more fall out.. I like how this is a pressed compact eyeshadow so great to take travelling.
Tips: Apply with your finger to get a better pigment.