e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner Review

I usually love ELF products but this liquid eyeliner was a huge miss for me. It's a bit transparent for my liking and it takes so long to dry that you end up smudging it everywhere. Granted I'm not the best at applying liquid eyeliner but every time I've used this I've ended up with eyeliner all over my hands and sometimes even nose which doesn't happen with other brands. I will not be purchasing this again.

I must admit, I tried this on a bit of a whim because I had used a few other products from the same brand that I liked. I already have a favourite every day liquid eyeliner, but it's pretty pricy and I decided to give something cheaper a go.

Initially I was pleased. I liked the fine brush and application was smooth and easy, if a little watery. I was able to build up the line gradually and neatly without too much trouble.

Unfortunately where this eyeliner soon let me down was in its staying power. It was already looking visibly faded a mere two or three hours after application. By lunch time there were a few decent flakes missing, leaving gaps in the line. By the time I got home from work, my wings had all but disappeared.

It didn't irritate my eyes but I was very, very disappointed with the overall effect. I demand thick black lines that stay there all day. I won't buy this again.

This is a great liquid liner for the price. I've tried others in the drugstore category but keep going back to this one.

I have the black and also brown which I use daily. I like the thin applicator it makes it really easy to get a thin precise line and wing. It is quiet a watery formula but dries well and fast.

Its not as opaque as i would like but it is easily buildable so that not really a big issue. I find that it does fade slightly after a few hours. If i have it on me i will just reapply it but its what i would expect for a product this cheap. I find it doesnt smudge at all which is quiet impressive.

i do really like this and will keep purchasing until i find something better. It definitely does the job well and is amazing for the price. I would recommend this to anyone who doesn't want to fork out a ton of money and just wants something reliable for daily wear.

I'm really impressed by these liquid liners, well the black one anyway! I have had the glitter ones before as well and while they look so pretty over top of the black line, they dried out so quickly so I wouldn't bother with those again.

Packaging is nice and simple. It's a decent pack size and the lid does up securely so you don't have to worry about leakage problems.

The brush tip is quite long and very fine so I find it easy to get a very thin line close to my lash line or I can thicken it up if I want to be more dramatic. The actual formula is reasonably dark, it's not the most pigmented liner ever but for a low end brand, it's really great. It's also quite a liquidy liner (well duh right!), but I find it really easy to apply and it also dries quick so won't smudge. On my lids this will last all day which is awesome and to make things even better, it's really easy to remove with makeup wipes.

I'm not totally sure if it would be the best liner for total beginners but it is pretty easy to use and so cheap to pick up.

I already have backups for this so would definitely buy again. I'm thinking about trying out some of the other colours too, like maybe purple or navy.

I have been on the hunt for a good black liquid eyeliner for a while and purchased this just to practice and have found I can't reach away from this product.

Firstly, I purchased this product due to all the hype about it and have found that it truely is worth it.

Now the packaging is lovely as you can seal it properly so the product lasts longer than other companies. The brush is perfect as the tip has a very fine point which makes the application easier and more precious. The formula is very black which I love as it means you don't have to layer it and I have found that it lasts all day.

This is definitely my holy grail liquid eyeliner.

The E.L.F liquid liner is a great product! Its not my favourite, but its good! Its affordable, Its true to colour, I find some liners say its black and its more on the grey side.

The packaging is nice and simple, the applicator is nice, its quite thin so its perfect to just line the tops of your lids!

It stays on all day and comes off really easy, sometimes I find other liners can really stick into your lashes!

Its a must have for any makeup hoarder :P

I have this eye liner in black and it is definitely my go to liner. It is easy to apply, either thick or thin and has a nice strong colour to it. I also find it doesn't end up rubbing off onto the rest of my eyelid like some of my other liners do. Plus the price makes it so affordable!

I love liquid eyeliner and this one is pretty good for a cheap brand.

I love the thin brush that allows you to control the thickness of your eyeliner.

The pigmentation is not the best but it is still quite dark. I just go over it a couple of times to intensify the look.

It doesn't flake or rub off like some other eyeliners do which is good.

The consistency is good too not too thick and not too thin.

It's not a great eyeliner but its good enough to use everyday.

This eyeliner is actually very good for the price! It comes in a sleek black package with a thin brush applicator which allows you to easily create the look you wanting to achieve.

The pigmentation is okay, I often used two coats to achieve a more intense colour. In saying that it is very longwearing and didn't go dry/flake off or rub/transfer through out the day.

I think this would be a great product for beginners due to the price and that it is a great formula.

I had heard about this eyeliner being raves about so I went out and brought myself some. The brush is amazing really good for getting the line that I want. But once I've put the eyeliner on, it goes patchy and all weird. Some parts are darker. I'm not sure if it's something Im doing