e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner Review

Not overly impressed with this liquid eye liner but for the price I can't really complain. One good thing about this is that I find it very easy to apply and I can get a good shape. The cons are that it doesn't last for very long literally can rub off in like 30 minutes, even when I set it with black eye shadow so it's not very long lasting.

This was one of the first liquid eyeliners I used to create a winged eye, and I've had a love/hate relationship with it ever since. First of all, I love the slim tip and the precise wing it creates. I also really like the small tube it comes in as its great for travelling with. I don't like that this eyeliner takes a while to dry, and smudges easily. The formula is quite thin, and is a light black, almost grey colour. I find that I always have to apply a few strokes of eyeliner over the same area to get the dark black colour I want. The staying power on this also isn't too great, smudges easily. I still come back to this eyeliner because of its thin tip and the precise lines it gives.. But the formula of this product dissapoints me. Would be great for beginners or when you aren't going out somewhere for a long amount of time. This is also very affordable :)

Decided to try this eyeliner out after my other E.L.F liquid eyeliner (in the cylinder tube) ran out. I didn't like the brush at all, I found I couldn't get a good wing from it because the brush was so thin. I found the colour was quite transparent too, so I needed to put multiple layers of it on. For the price you can't really complain, but I'll definitely be sticking to my other eyeliner.

This eyeliner is a good value for the cheap price. I find that it goes on easily, though it can go on a bit thin. So sometimes I end up doing two layers. Once dry after a few hours I do find it cracks a bit, so if you're making any obvious cat-eye statements this probably isn't the product for it.

Was so excited to dive into e.l.f's products for the first time. I bought this liner in the shade charcoal and in store the whole bottle looked black but now that I look at it, it's like a dark bluey grey on the bottom of the bottle. The brush is too thick to get a very pointed wing so your wing is going to be so blunt. I found it a bit watery but it's pigmented and dries nicely. When I took it off the first time with a makeup wipe I laughed because it came off so easily and it's definitely going to run down your face if you cry or get caught in the rain, and for the price it's disappointing that it's not even waterproof in the slightest. I still use this product but not for long periods of time because it won't stay. I'm sure this brand has nicer products but beware of this one.

I think this is a good eyeliner for starting out your eyeliner journey, I found the applicator very easy but had to go over and set with black eyeshadow to create the desired colour I wanted. The price is good but once you have the hang of eyeliner I would move onto a more pigmented eyeliner

I usually love ELF products but this liquid eyeliner was a huge miss for me. It's a bit transparent for my liking and it takes so long to dry that you end up smudging it everywhere. Granted I'm not the best at applying liquid eyeliner but every time I've used this I've ended up with eyeliner all over my hands and sometimes even nose which doesn't happen with other brands. I will not be purchasing this again.

I had heard about this eyeliner being raves about so I went out and brought myself some. The brush is amazing really good for getting the line that I want. But once I've put the eyeliner on, it goes patchy and all weird. Some parts are darker. I'm not sure if it's something Im doing

This Elf liquid eyeliner is one of the easiest to apply. The packing is very simple and compact. The extra thin brush makes application very quick and painless, however the formula is so watery that it takes ages to dry.

Once the liner has dried, it loses a lot of pigment. Jet black liner dries to become a sad grey colour. I would not recommend for people with monolids - it does not have the stay power.

I must admit, I tried this on a bit of a whim because I had used a few other products from the same brand that I liked. I already have a favourite every day liquid eyeliner, but it's pretty pricy and I decided to give something cheaper a go.

Initially I was pleased. I liked the fine brush and application was smooth and easy, if a little watery. I was able to build up the line gradually and neatly without too much trouble.

Unfortunately where this eyeliner soon let me down was in its staying power. It was already looking visibly faded a mere two or three hours after application. By lunch time there were a few decent flakes missing, leaving gaps in the line. By the time I got home from work, my wings had all but disappeared.

It didn't irritate my eyes but I was very, very disappointed with the overall effect. I demand thick black lines that stay there all day. I won't buy this again.