I'll start out by saying I'm a huge fan of Essie polishes. However I was a little let down by this top coat.
Pros: As per most Essie polishes, it was easy to apply and the formula settled well on the nail (no brush strokes visible). It also dried quickly, which is always a plus for me (nothing bothers me more than waiting for polish to dry...)
Cons: It's not a very shiny top coat (maybe less of a con for others, but I love a good shiny finish!). It also didn't feel like it extended my mani very much, I noticed a few chips and peeling around day 5.
I think applying a second layer of top coat a few days after the initial top coat would help extend the wear, but that sort of defeats the purpose.
I paint my nails almost every week. I'm not a fan of gel polish or other long-wear polish options ie. dipping powder because of the removal process that no matter how tediously careful leaves them paper thin. This does mean that I spend a couple of hours a week towards having neat polished tips. For some background on my day-to-day in terms of my activities with regard to my manicure longevity with regular polish, I rinse and load the dishwasher, with serious, cleaning, handwashing dishes, and chores involving detergents I wear gloves and when I'm cooking dinner I wear gloves, I cook dinner 3 nights a week. But I do cook my breakfast and prep my lunch in the morning without gloves which involves a bit of chopping. I have short nails because I work doing deep tissue and facial massage. I'm a frequent hand-washer as well. I don't spend time soaking in the bath but I take longer hot showers. Essie is my favourite brand of polish because I like the rounded tip of the brush, that makes it easier for me to do a neater job near the cuticle. I have been using Essie's All-in-One Base and Top Coat which for reference starts wearing off at the tips in about two days. I usually do 2 coats of that over my colour and by the second day the colour is slightly worn off on the tips but not that noticeable since I wear nude shades. At the time of writing this review, I'm halfway through my bottle of Essie All-in-One so it's thickened and takes a while to dry completely. I read the instructions for Essie Stay Longer and it said to just do one layer of the top coat. So once my colour was dry and won’t leave imprints if I touched it, I applied a thin layer of Essie Stay Longer and capped the tips. It went on smoothly; I could see just a smidge of my colour come off on the brush when I painted the top coat. Waited for the top coat to completely dry and be non-imprintable before doing anything else. The next day I had a hard chip of polish come off on one of my ring fingers, so just painted a bit over the chipped area with my colour and painted over the whole nail with another layer of Essie Stay Longer. The following day I had another hard chip of polish come off the tip of my middle finger so I did the same thing as I did the previous day. The manicure stayed looking fine and started wearing off at the tips within a few days. I didn't have any more hard chipping that week. The next week I painted my nails I opted for two coats of Essie Stay Longer, to see how long my mani would last this time. My middle finger chipped the next day, so I fixed it up. And then polished chipped off the side of my other middle finger the next day and the tips wore off like usual. I wouldn’t say this top coat out performs any of the other ones I have tried from Essie. I probably would try another top coat I haven’t tried from Essie to see if it’s better than this one.
Tips: You'll get more longevity with two top coats.