e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner Review

I'm not a huge fan of liquid eyeliner and the reason is that I'm not good at applying eyeliner. The reason I purchased this eyeliner was because it was cheap, but promised that it would give precision upon application and be dramatic on eyes.... Lies!

Firstly the quality of the eyeliner is like water. Its so running and when you apply it onto your eye its not black at all. Because its a watery consistency, the application gives a sheer line which needs millions of more application to have an opaque line.

That tip... Dreadful! I cannot get precise application and the tip is so weak and more like a paintbrush than a makeup brush. I much prefer a shorter condense brush for more control over the long brush that comes with this eyeliner.

This eyeliner doesnt get any love from me and I'm scared to pass it along to anybody else in fear that they will hate it.

I find this really easy to use. The brush is not hard so you don't end up poking your eye. The formula of the eyeliner is runny but it makes application smooth.

The thing I do not like is that sometimes the brush can have faults, such as a strand poking out which is annoying.

I Love elf products, but truth be told, they can be pretty hit or miss, and this was a big, fat, let down! I'm still pretty bitter about it (even though it was only $3)l

I brought this on iherb, so yes it was $3. A great price for an eyeliner if you ask me. I had read a lot of reviews, and people were calling this their holy grail. A holy grail eyeliner for $3? That was enough to make me whip out the old credit card.

This liner comes in the same packaging as the revlon one. It comes in a small container, with a wand that it attached to the lid. Simply turn the lid to pull out the wand.

The wand has an almost paint brush tip on the end, its really soft and thin so relatively easy to draw that perfect line. However, the formula is very smooth and runny which means it is quite easy to make a mess of your eyeliner if you are not paying attention.

This eyeliner goes on black as night, which is exactly what I want. But by the end of the day, the black had faded, and it is more a charcoal grey which is not a good look. I will keep trying to love this eyeliner, maybe I just got a bad bottle, I will never know... but for the time being I will be sticking with me Za Liquid liner.. that thing is amazing!

This eye liner is great quality for an amazing cheap price I got this in a 3 pack with two other glitter ones from the elf Us website for $1. It is quite watery/wet and can become very messy when applying if you're not a confident liquid liner wearer I am not sure how you would go or maybe its perfect for a beginner I am actually not sure but for how cheap I am sure its worth a try. The wand has a flexible brush applicator on the end not a stiff one which is good I don't have a preference I like to try all different applicators. Does not have the best staying power it doesn't keep the intense deep black that originally has when you first apply but you can touch it up it doesn't fade to the point of no return.

The E.L.F liquid liner is a great product! Its not my favourite, but its good! Its affordable, Its true to colour, I find some liners say its black and its more on the grey side.

The packaging is nice and simple, the applicator is nice, its quite thin so its perfect to just line the tops of your lids!

It stays on all day and comes off really easy, sometimes I find other liners can really stick into your lashes!

Its a must have for any makeup hoarder :P

I will put a disclaimer here - using this eyeliner was the first time I have used a liquid liner, however I have repeatedly used it to practice but I still found it temperamental. When I first used it I found it very hard to get the coverage I wanted. I like a nice solid dark line, this came out really faded so I had to go over it a few times to get what I wanted. The next time I tried it, the liner was so liquidy it bled, so I looked like I had tried some terrible halloween make-up or something. The good thing was though - it was finally dark enough. Now when I do use it I ensure I have something on hand to wipe up any "bleed" straight away. I'm not so sure I would buy this again. If you're after a cheap fix then this is it, but if you're after a good quality flawless liner then this is not for you.

I have this eye liner in black and it is definitely my go to liner. It is easy to apply, either thick or thin and has a nice strong colour to it. I also find it doesn't end up rubbing off onto the rest of my eyelid like some of my other liners do. Plus the price makes it so affordable!

I tried out the e.l.f liquid eyeliner recently to practice doing my winged eyeliner. The packaging is nice, it comes with a small applicator brush to apply it with. When I applied this to my eye lid the I found I had to paint on quite a few layers to make it look good, the little brush was very hard to apply it with and I kept smudging the eyeliner. I also found this eye liner really hard to remove even when using makeup wipes or remover it seemed to stain the skin around my eyes. I think this eyeliner is okay for the price, but I will not be repurchasing as it was to fiddly to use.

I picked this liner up for three dollars on i herb and I have to say for the price its proven to be a great purchase! The packaging is nice and sleek and it has a long handle on the applicator so easy to control when applying.

Now, if you like thick liquid eyeliner thats super pigmented and are not so fussed if the applicator is a bit bigger then i would direct you to the studio precision eyeliner in the e.l.f range. But! If you are all about the applicator brush being teeny and precise and are wanting a thin line then this one is great for you!

The brush on this liquid eyeliner is one of the best i've seen around, its super fine and allows you to be very precise. I do however find that the formula is a lot thinner so it takes a couple of coats to build up the opacity if you are wanting to do a thicker line.However, I tend to use this liner for an everyday look so the formula doesn't bother me that much.

This liner is very affordable and I would recommend it to anyone who is after a super fine brush!

I am totally useless at liquid liner, previous attempts at applying it have left me with bright red stinging eyes because I just couldn't get it in the right place and it kept running into my eye! But not with this stuff!

This liquid liner is amazing! It's so easy to apply, it glides on so smoothly and gives a nice clean sharp dark line, without having to go over it a million times.

The packaging is pretty simple but the little brush is the perfect size, making it so easy to get it right where you want it.

I still need a whole lot more practice with it, but I see this becoming a fav once I get the hang of it. Whats not to love about it?!