Stila Stay All Day Eyeliner Pen Review

This is a fairly recent addition to my eyeliner collection. I'm a little bit of an eyeliner hoarder, as I'm constantly searching for a liquid liner that has a super fine tip, is pigmented and that stays on all day.

This came as a part of a kit I ordered from Sephora. I'd never tried any liquid liners from Stila but like their pencil loners, so I was keen to give this a go.

As with Stilas pencil liners, the packaging on this is nice. It is a slim pen that is easy to hold and manoeuvre around your eye. The tip of this pen is super fine - which instantly made me happy. As the name of it suggests, this is a pen liner.

The pigmentation is awesome and the product comes out super black, with a semi glossy finish once dried. It doesn't look wet or anything, but it isn't truly matte. True to the claims, this is waterproof as well as smudge proof. I easily get a whole days wear (10 hours at least), without it budging, fading or flaking off.

Because the tip of the pen is so fine, it is very easy to create an extremely precise line with razor sharp edges. If you're looking for a liner that is thin and precise then I urge you to give this a go.

I have this in black (on my second tube!) and dark brown and it's definitely my holy grail liquid liner! It has a lovely fine tipped pen that doesn't shed or start to fall apart like some do, and is absolutely fantastic for fine, precise lines.

It's a richly pigmented liner, the black is a true deep black which I adore. The precision and accuracy is fantastic for quick and easy liner looks on the go, and it really does stay put miraculously well compared to others I've tried. I can wear it for 12 hours plus and at worst it might wear a little in the inner corners. I've even slept in this bad boy, and the wings mostly flaked off but the rest was still going strong!!

It's not cheap, but I've found that it lasts a good long time and doesn't dry out quickly like some other liquid pens do (I'm looking at you, Maybelline!).

It also dries wonderfully fast, which is superb for those of us whose lash line touches their upper lids when their eyes are open!

Now I actually bought mine in Singapore. I walked into (okay I'm lying I RAN) into the local sephora at Ion Orchard and spoke to a sales girl. I asked for a recommendation on a liquid liner that would not budge as I have super oily eyelids. She handed me this and said that I would get the most precise cat eyeliner ever. Well she wasn't wrong! I marched around Singapore's humid weather and this baby did not budge. I was sweating buckets for hours and my eyeliner stayed as fresh as the hour I applied it. I actually bought a back up in Bangkok because I was so in love. Beautiful black, unmovable eyeliner that is so sharp. Highly recommend

It actually lasts all day! I finally found my holy grail! I have very watery eyes which means my liquid eyeliner always smudges and comes off very easily. Except for this one! This is the best I've ever tried. At the end of the day my eyeliner looks as good as it did when I put it on in the morning and it applies like a dream, exact lines and perfect flicks. Absolutely 100% recommend.

This is an excellent liquid eyeliner. The pen style is easy to use and you have great control of it. The tip is fine and flexible so it is easy to get the perfect winged liner.

My favourite thing about this eyeliner is how opaque the formula is. It really is very black. However, it dries to a shiny finish so if you like matte black liners then this is probably not for you.

The staying power of this eyeliner is outstanding. I have monolidded eyes so most eyeliners transfer to above where I apply the liner. This does not. It stays the whole day, hence the name, and I have even gone swimming with it on, in Fiji, where I was sweating like crazy and had a greasy face from sunscreen.

It removes easily using my favourite eye makeup remover, Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover.

This eyeliner comes in so many beautiful colours, I want them all!

I'm not the best at winged liner but this product helps to give me more control over what I'm trying to achieve on my hooded lids. I bought mine from Mecca Cosmetica for $32.00.

I have the shade Intense Black and it comes in sleek black packaging with silver print. The silver print can wear off depending on how you handle your beauty items. It's the size of a standard pen and fits perfectly in the palm of your hand.

It has a fine felt tip that has just enough flexibility to allow you to easily sweep the tip from outer corner to mid lid. You can create fine or thick lines based on the angle you use it so there's no issue in creating natural or dramatic wings. The colour goes on a lovely wet black and dries to a vivid black - it's not matte but it's not particularly shiny either.

I love that it's a fast drying product which is fantastic for me because I have hooded lids so often when I open my eye, the eyeliner is still wet and the excess skin picks up the product because I've been a bit too overzealous with the application. I can make a lot of mistakes with this eyeliner and not get product on other areas of the eye area!

The product does NOT budge and I only notice a bit of fading by the end of the day which is fantastic for me and my oily hooded lids! The product comes off easily with a makeup wipe (no need to tug or rub) or makeup remover - I am repurchasing this gem!

I think this eyeliner is one of the best in the market.

It is so black and applies really well. The pen itself isn't very dry so makes application easy where you don't have to keep going over the area to make it darker.

It was recommended to me by one of the girls and Mecca and I'm glad I purchased it as I do reach for it very often and over my other eyeliners

I love this eyeliner so much! I have been using (and repurchasing) it for about 2 years now.

I love it because the shape makes it super easy to draw a perfect line across your lids and the pen is also quite thin so you can control it easier. Another benefit is that it really truly does last the whole day.

Before this I used the Maybelline Master Precise - which is very similar just a bit thinner - but I had to change because the master precise was not drawing properly overtop my more thick eyeshadows (think Mac or Maybelline paint pots). This Stila eyeliner applies perfectly over both thin and thicker eyelid colours without damaging the pen and so that makes it a win for me.

I have been using this product for about a month now and have used it most days. I cannot get over how good it is!

The product comes in a slick black tube with gold writing. The applicator is like a felt tip end, similar to other products such as the ZA eye liner. It is not super fine, but still gives an accurate application with the nib getting wider as it gets closer to the barrel.

This eyeliner really does last and only budges when there is moisture and rubbing of the area where the product is. I have this weird issue that my eyes water when it's windy so things tend to disappear off my lids if there is wind, but with this product my eyes are lined and they stay lined all day! The colour is an intense black, highly pigmented so you don't need to go over and over. I like the way it applies, and with little practice this pen applicator is a good option for beginners or people in a rush.

I would definitely buy again!