This mascara is pretty good, and it seems to mostly do what it says it will. So, things I like about it... (#1) It doesn't smudge and give me panda-eyes (#2) It lasts through the day (#3) Very easy to remove, a washcloth will take it off (#4) It doesn't clump at all!
So these are all really, really good things right? What I don't get with this mascara is any lengthening or body to it. I have very fine, shortish lashes and I just don't find this mascara gives me the oomph that I'm trying to find in a mascara. So while I like it lots, and I would definitely recommend it for people with longer, fuller lashes... I'm afraid I'm still looking for my perfect 5/5 mascara *sigh*
I received a mini version of this as part of a Clinique GWP. The brush applicator looked promising, it is of the natural bristle variety and looks like it would give you lots of volume. Unfortunately this did nothing for my lashes, gave me no volume, only a little length and didn't hold a curl very well. I also found that it flaked off my lashes somewhat throughout the day. After a couple of uses I have thrown this one out- lifes too short for a bad mascara!
This one is hugely popular but unfortunately did not work for my lashes so wouldn't personally recommend it.