Maybelline The Colossal Cat's Eyes

If I could give no stars, I would.

I bought this feeling really excited and optimistic. All other mascaras bring out my length and curl so well that I never use extensions.

I used this and multiple things happened: 1. All my eyelashes clumped together, so it looked like I had about 5 fly legs on my eye lids. 2. The mascara itself seemed incredibly runny. It was like a liquid that took forever to dry. 3. I got small amount of cat eye-ness, which is the only positive I had from this whole experience. 4. It seems to get onto your eye lids when you put it on - this is weird and never happened to me before, even with different shaped brushes. 5. After an hour, it then flaked off my lashes onto my face.

This was a real disappointment for me - I was really looking forward to a new Maybelline mascara.

I wish I had read reviews on here before I purchased this. I also wish that mascaras could be 'try before buy.' Such is life, I have learnt, now!!

Maybelline collosal lash is my favourite mascara so when I saw this I figured it would just be a step up! However I was wrong. I brought two of these mascaras of a grabone deal and have been dissapointed.

For one it feels as if theres hardly any product in the bottles. Secondly the brush shape is actually hard to use and feels like youre hardly putting any product on your lashes. I am still continuing to use it as it does make my lashes long but I wouldn't really recommend this to anyone. I got it for a really good price so am happy to continue using but for retail price its not worth the money.

I'm not 100% sold, seems very watery and is a lil messy. I don't feel it coats my lashes as well as other mascaras.

Clumpy, it looked like i had 5 eyelashes, the formula is runny and takes ages to dry. The brush is shocking also in my opinion. The waterproof one is so hard to get off literally nearly ripped my eyelashes out.

This Mascara is ok. I wouldn't pay full retail for it or even brag about it. It is extremely wet to apply and takes a super long time to apply. It does give you longer looking lashes & stays on all night and I like the curve of the brush. It also seems to clump a lot, not Maybellines best work.

I really like this mascara. It does create a great cat eye look with practically zero effort.

I've found I often end up getting tiny dots of mascara on my eyelid just above my lashline, but that could be user error at this point.

I have th waterproof version and I've found it has great staying power.

I really really love the brush, and think I might buy the non-waterproof version next time because I like it so much.

I got mine for 50% off which was a great deal - I'm not sure I'd feel quite so enthusiastic about it if I had paid full RRP though.

This mascara separated my lashes, made them very black and super long! I've had this mascara for a while and the formula is still very watery, not think and chunky at all. This mascara has a wand that I love! I bought mine in waterproof, and it is truly waterproof! The only bad thing is that it is so hard to get off!

This is the most amazing mascara I have ever tried and owned. My holy grail make up product of all time!

It gives my lashes the perfect amount of volume, length and also gives my lashes a little flirty tough at the ends giving it a slight cat eye effect. I also really love the brush. I must be honest, I thought the brush looked really weird and scary at first, but I just love it so, so much!

I have got my friends hooked on this mascara. It gives my lashes a nice long curled look which I love. Sometimes it can get a bit flaky and a bit clumpy if you layer it too much. But overall I really like it, its not my ultimate fav but its up there.

Love this mascara, so thick and elongating. Sometimes it goes on a bit clumpy sure but I do like that! Just. So perfect. And so affordable. Bought 2 in one go and DO NOT REGRET IT AT ALL. Best buy!