This Neutrogena makeup remover is one of the best! It completely removes all my eye makeup (waterproof mascara, eyeliner & liquid liner) It is very gentle when removing and no need for harsh rubbing. It has a oily feeling, so I always rinse my eyes with water after.
Overall I would highly recommend this product due to its success in removing makeup and its affordable cost.
This really works on any type of eye product you have on! To me this is very similar to lancome bi-facil eye makeup remover, so at a fraction of the price you are better off with this one. I must be like on my fourth bottle - it does what it is supposed too and is sooo gentle. On the daily I wear eye shadow, liner (liquid, gel, waterproof) and DollyWink volume mascara (if you haven't tried this it is the best but a pain to take off). It all comes off with Neutrogena's remover.
It says it's oil-free but it feels oily... funny that, but it's not a biggie. You are meant to rinse off afterwards anyways. I use it before jumping in the shower.
Highly recommended eye makeup remover!
Tips: hmmm I sometimes use this also to take off dark lipstick :) it works so why not!