Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Review

Great product, does exactly what it says it should do. Mascara and eyeliner is removed in one swipe, and you don't have to use much product for it to work. Very pleased with it :)

It worked great and I use waterproof makeup thickly!! As promised on the bottle it wasn't oily like others I have tried and removed every trace of makeup in a couple of wipes. Had no irritation and when it dribbled into my eyes it didn't sting and washed out very easy.

I brought this because it was "oil free" - it does a great job of taking off my stubborn water proof eye makeup but it is so oily!

It leaves this horrible oily film on my face and I feel like I need to go and re wash my face to take it off.

I can't decide what my final verdict is on this one - it's the best I have used for taking off all of my makeup without leaving that shadow effect from the mascara but I really don't like the oiliness of it..

I'm not too sure about this product. It says its Oil Free but the product in the bottle looks oily? It didn't get all of my eye makeup off but I would use it again as it did do a good job, just not fantastic!

Trying out the Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover I didn't expect anything special. I thought they would work about as well as the make up remover wipes I use but with out the convenience of being in wipe form. But I was completely blown away! I used one square cotton pad with a bit of the remover for each eye and it COMPLETELY removed every trace of my eye shadow, liquid eye-liner and water proof mascara in less then a minute. I simply wiped my eyelids and under my eyes a few times, paying extra attention to my eyelashes and then rinsed it off with warm water. I didn't have to pinch my eye lashes to try 'pull' the mascara off like I usually do, breaking off a couple lashes in the process. I couldn't believe how easy and painless my make up came off! My eyes were left feeling soft and clean instead of red and a bit puffy for once. I will 100% buy this again and recommend it to all my friends

This is an awesome make-up remover! It deff does remove all traces of make-up, especially water-proof eyeliner etc! It is oil free so especially good for those of us with lash extensions!

Hey, I have been using neutrogena eye makeup remover for 3 years and I find it is perfect when wearing contact lenses. I can even use it to remove mascara without having to take contact lenses out without being overly oily or stinging. Totally a keeper!

This product says it's oil free, but it just doesn't feel like that. It definitely removes the eye makeup no problems, but it leaves an almost oily residue behind. This is great for use before you jump in the shower, as your shower routine would get off the residue. I just found it a little oily for me and I wouldn't use it again.

For me this one have the same result as Loareal but I love this packaging because I can dip my cotton buts in!!! With loareal its hardly to get products.

Best eye make remover I have ever used. I have recommended it to many friends. It is gentle, does not sting and really has no fragrance.