Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Review

I absolutely swear by this product. My skin in dry in winter and the oil free eye makeup remover works perfectly well to removed the water proof mascara, eyeliner under the eyes and also long stay revelon lipstick that is quite hard to removed with a normal makeup remover. My only complain is it can be a little heavy for people with oily skin and face needs to be washed after the makeup remover has been used.

I often get quite red undereyes after an entire day of wearing make-up and this product takes EVERYTHING off perfectly and leaves my eyes feeling refreshed. Waterproof mascara doesn't even stand a chance

Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Make-Up Remover is FANTASTIC for removing my waterproof make-up.

I swear by this stuff, it takes off everything without being harsh on my skin, its wonderful.

I wear a heck of a lot of extremely water resistant, won't budge, hurricane proof mascara and eyeliner for work and if I take a tissue, add a bit of the stuff to it, it swipes my eyefull of make-up off in second. Like magic.

The only negative part is that it does leave a slight oil-like residue on your skin, I suppose thats just a moisturising component but I'm super particular about oil on my face, it comes off with quick wash. Funny, because the formula is oil-free, so I'm pretty sure its nothing nasty.

Wonderful product, an essential in my bathroom.

The Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover is great if you use alot of heavy eye makeup, or waterproof products as it will remove it well! But for more basic, non-waterproof products it's probably not needed & could use something else if preferred.

I did notice that this product is "oil-free", but seriously... this product is pretty damn oily for oil-free.

When I initially tried the nutrogena eye make up remover I admit I was skeptical of how it was going to pull though, BUT, I have to admit it is extremely good! I find I need to use a very little amount (put a make up removes pad over the opening, turn the bottle upside down and that is enough) and it is great at removing all my mascara etc in literally a couple of wipes!

I wear thick gel eyeliner everyday. And this small bottle tends to remove all of it at once (except for the eyeliner stuck between my lashes). Extra gentle formula is a bonus. It didnt hurt my eyes at all when I accidentally touched my eyeballs with the cotton pads (silly, but we all know it's not just me!) Such a great product- The only thing that stops me from buying is that now I use cleansing oil to remove all the make-up so I really don't need a separate bottle just for my eyes . If I wore a light make-up, I would definitely use it again.

This is probably the best make up remover that i have used. It just removes your eye make up with one quick swipe. Neutrogena say it is oil free but it feels a tad oily on my skin so i use it before i wash my face, no problems!

I've used this in the past and recently re-purchased it as it has been very difficult to find the usual eye makeup remover I use.

I wear eyeliner and the occasional mascara and all I do is shake the bottle, dip a cotton tip into the bottle and clean off my makeup, Everything comes off without much effort at all!

I'm a big fan of the fact that this product removes all eye makeup i.e waterproof mascara, eyeliner etc but doesn't irritate your eyes. It's SO gentle! It does require a couple of swipes to get it off (what makeup remover doesn't?!), but you don't have to rub hard at all.

The only drawback is that i find I have to use quite a bit for each use, but I mean I use it daily and it still lasts about 1-2 months so it's not really an issue, especially if you can buy it on special.

Alrighty I've tried quite a few eye make up removers and basically all of them, no matter what they claim, made my eyes sting and go red and itch and all the rest of it. But not only does this product NOT sting my eyes, it also WORKS. It's so incredibly easy for me to take off my eyeshadow (including cream eyeshadows), my waterproof liquid eyeliner, my pencil eyeliner that's super hard to take off and best of all, my mascara. Why is my mascara best of all? Because, ladies, I use They're Real mascara. That's right. The only claim it doesn't fulfill is the fact that it DOES leave an oily residue behind.

Update: It is now March and the last couple of days I have used this it has stung/made my eyes itchy. I'm thinking it's probably just gone bad? I'm almost to the bottom. If you've had this kind of trouble please let me know.