Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Review

I found this remover to be quite oily (even though its meant to be oil free) & took a lot of rubbing to remove my eyeliner.

I don't know about you but I am all for value for money. yes this product was gentle, did remove even waterproof mascara (did take a few goes however) but the things that annoyed me was that the liquid often gets soaked into my cotton ball. I am not sure if someone has a better tip but I felt like I was using a quarter of the bottle at a time, also the bottle opening was huge, if you aren't careful the entire bottle can tip out! Would be great if they made this formula in a wipe or a cream cleanser to perhaps me less wasteful. Overall I thought it was average, did the job but has to use a lot!

I have to say I think this is a fabulous eye makeup remover.

It makes removing waterproof mascara a breeze (which as we know can be quite stubborn to remove).

I like to leave the cotton pad on my eye for about 10 seconds before wiping the makeup away.

It is very gentle and there is no stinging which is great. But, the remover leaves an ‘oily’ residue after use even though it is meant to be oil-free …so not too sure what it is if it’s not oil?

The only downfall for me is that overtime it left my eye area very dry (skin flaking kind of dry) so unfortunately for that reason I won’t be repurchasing it.

Good price and a little goes a long way so it lasts a while.

I have bought this product a couple of times, not because I love it, mostly because I am so undecided about it. I find I have to use a lot of the product to remove my eye make up, also the makeup pads soak up a lot. You definately need to place the make up pad over your eyes & hold for awhile then swipe gently. I have to use a combination of make up pads & cotton buds otherwise I wake up with panda eyes from remaining residue. I really like the texture of the remover, it feels very smooth & silky around the eye once the makeup has been removed, it doesn't sting at all which I am happy about as I have very sensitive eyes. I would prefer the bottle had a small dripper or cap where you could control the amount that was coming out, it would make it a lot easier to use. I think next time around I'll purchase another product to compare, it might help me to decide if this will be a future repurchase.

1) the product removes make up effectively

2) I would not say it was great or bad, but did as it said

3) Would use again but I am not now converted to using ONLY this for my eye make up removing

This product is great it removes all my eye make up well and it is a good price but what I don't like about this product is that it feel so oily on my skin and leave a very oily residue even tho this is a oil free make up remover so I have to wash my face after using this product to remove the oil left behind. Well I have continued to use this product well I have it i doubt I'll rebuy this

I have been using this for a couple of weeks now and I have to start off my saying I wasn't expecting too much with it being oil free. I have found this make up remover to be pretty good and it compares well to the high end oil based make up removers that I have used in the past. This removes all traces of the bright, bold and sometimes hard to remove lippy's that I love to wear. It also does a really good job on eye make up and I have been happy with its efficiency at removing eye make up. The only thing I don't like about the product is the big open top to the bottle. Other similar products to this I have used have a small opening which is great to help you not waste product. I find with the big open top I am getting through this really quickly and for this reason alone probably won't purchase it again.

Despite the name saying this product is oil-free, I found it to leave my skin feeling quite oily after using it, meaning that I would have to make sure I wash my face again after using this eye make up remover to remove the oily residue, but that fact aside, it did remove my eye make up fast.

Product does a great job at removing eye makeup and at a really affordable price. I did feel that my skin felt oily afterwards which I didn't like. It felt like I then had to cleanse again to get rid of the oil. Will finish the bottle, but I don't think I'll be purchasing again.