I purchased a selection of these off of NYX directly recently during their huge 4th of July sale and was awesomely impressed! Firstly I ordered them as I loved how cute they looked with the barrel and lid of the lipstick container matching its colour to the lipstick inside and have heard nothing but good things about them.
As mentioned above they have the cutest packaging for lipsticks in this price range, with their branding embossed in white and the easy to use twist up motion and a lid that snaps shut rather than sort of closes and then pops off in your bag kind of lid, this means that I can safely carry my lipstick with me throughout the day should I need a top up.
Lasting power shown by the butter range is great, I applied the 2 coats in the morning, blotted and only needed to top up after lunch for a full day coverage, this was mainly the case for the darker shades but found that a couple of the pink/salmon tones tend to wash away on my face during the day, regardless if I have eaten or drunk anything.
The lipstick itself is very luxurious to put on, it does feel like butter but not in the gross way, it’s smooth and almost melts onto your lips for a plump full look with even coverage of its highly pigmented colour. I have 8 of these that range from light beige, reds, pink, coral and deep plums, out of all of them my favourite is Liquorice it’s the most perfect purple plum I own without being over the top.
I have the shade 'Hot Tamale' which I just had to get after seeing a member wearing this on Instagram. It is a beautiful, bright, in your face Orange/red. Definitely more orange than red but so much fun to wear.
What I love about these lipsticks is now nice they feel on the lips. The colour glides on easily, and it feels so smooth to rub your lips together. And it has a great colour pay off. With this bright shade especially I didn't need to put on much more than a swipe, but of course you can layer it up.
I did find that the colour stuck around for quite sometime. I wouldn't stay it was smudge proof, but it did leave me with a fair bit of colour for most of my day. It would need a touch up after eating.
I also really love how the packaging of these lip sticks are very true to the colour of the lipstick it's self, as there is a clear middle section that allows you to see the true colour.
Im really impressed with the price point on these too. I plan to add more to my collection soon.
Tips: I would suggest wearing a lip liner, as the creamy buttery texture of these lipsticks means that they have a tendency to move around a bit.