I found this micellar water to be too oily even with the product shaken thoroughly. It did leave residue on my skin that felt greasy and I used another cleanser to remove it.
It removed my mascara well but it was a bit messy, (spreading the mascara accross my eyes in streaks) than with the normal Garnier Micellar Water which does the job well too without the mess.
It also stung my eyes quite a bit and I don't like the idea of the oil in my eyes so I stopped using it. I personally would not reccomend this and I would only use it again if I ran out of my other micellar.
I have used this to remove eye makeup for years now and never fails! It is a tad oily, so if you can't stand that then i wouldn't recommend. Other than that, it gets stubborn and waterproof makeup off with no trouble. Does what it says it does.
Tips: Make sure two colours have mixed thoroughly before used.A little goes a pretty long way.