Simple Kind to Eyes Eye Makeup Remover

It might just be me, I have super sensitive eyes and allergies and I have to use eyedrops on a daily basis because my eyes get red and itchy. But this stuff just made it worse. Definitely worked to remove the make up, not so much the harder stuff like my gel eyeliner, but it worked. So if you're anything like me, I wouldn't buy this.

I had high hopes for this product as I had heard good things about it. But I really disliked it! I wear heavy eye makeup most days so I need something that will remove it smoothly but also be gentle on my skin, I felt with this eye makeup remover I was rubbing at my eyes and even when I was done It hadn't removed it all, it also isn't gentle on the skin and really really stung not only my eyes but my eyelids!

I have the Simple Toner and have tried their make up wipes - both which I like and I am still using the toner. Unfortunately this eye make up remover doesn't do what I need it to do at all! It says that it will remove waterproof mascara but didn't do much for me - just smudged the mascara around a bit. It doesn't really get rid of eyeliner either. So maybe this is more for people who just wear light makeup. Very disappointed with this product.

Both my mum and I have normal skin, not sensitive, we don't have sensitive eyes or anything. We BOTH used this once and will never go there again. It hurt our eyes, made our eyes feel incredibly irritated (and yes, we did use it the correct way). Neither of us have EVER had a reaction to ANYTHING, so the fact this happened to both of us is rather alarming. Also, we found that it did sh*t all to remove our eye make up. I don't hate products, but I seriously hate this one.

I don't have sensitive skin but when I used this "eye makeup remover" I had burning eyelids. I had to wash with water then Milk to settle my skin. For the next three days I had red raw eyes. Not cool!!

I will never buy this again. It was a very disappointing product from Simple!

It was completely useless at removing my makeup! I couldn't get this formula to remove my mascara, even when it wasn't a waterproof one! I had to constantly go over my eyes and that is not ideal at all. A few lost lashes and sore eyes later, I ended up throwing it out!

i really did not like this! its smudged my eye makeup everywere!!!!!!! i dont know if its just me but it stung my eyes and they were red and puffy the next day. i really wouldnt recommend this to my friends/family

I have sensitive skin so of course I gravitated towards the Simple range. I bought the Eye makeup remover and cleansing wipes as well. After my first use of the eye makeup remover my skin felt tight and dry. The lids of my eyes turned red and my skin was even more sensitive. It didn't remove my mascara. I almost had to scrub my eyes with it. Not gentle at all. I thought maybe my skin just has to get use to the new stuff, the second use was it for me, it felt like my eyes were burning. It hurt to move them! And after all that hassle my mascara and liquid liner still didn't come off. I gave it away to a friend who uses Simple. And she says it's alright not that great.

I actually haven't used this product for a while now, what has prompted me to write this review is that I found this at the back of the cupboard the other day, 90% full, and it went straight into the bin!

Personally this could not take off my favourite mascara which is waterproof. It worked ok on the shadow and liner. There is also a bit of "pull' when wiping off eye makeup, it's not a smooth swipe like when using Neutrogena's remover.

The main reason for buying is that Simple products are great for sensitive skin and you want gentle products for use near your eyes - but this just did not live up to it's claims.

Bought this because I could not find my usual eye makeup remover at the supermarket, and this caught my eye as it was on special. I wear eyeliner and sometimes mascara. I tried to clean off my eyeliner with a cotton pad, and almost nothing came off so i drenched the cotton pad with the makeup remover and still hardly anything came off!

It was a waste of money and you could achieve the same results using just water!