I was really excited when buying this at duty free and bought the black one, but am not fully impressed with it. I found that the pigmentation was definitely there, and it easily glided on, but it definitely wasn't 24/7.
Within 3 hours, it had started smudging, and the liner on my upper lid, had transferred to below my eyes and into my inner corners, giving me the appearance of panda eyes. I love the colour, pigmentation, and formula but it is quite pricey and doesn't stay put. I also feel that it isn't waterproof and is quite a hassle to constantly sharpen. It doesn't sit well in the tightline or waterline.
I would not repurchase unfortunately. :(
I have these Urban Decay eye pencils in three shades: Stash, Rockstar and Zero. I love that they apply really easily to both the waterline and eyelid and that once they set, they do last well for me. The pencils glide on easily without dragging the skin. The colours are gorgeous also with Stash being my favourite as it’s a warm gold green that makes my hazel eye colour “pop”.