This was my first UD product I have used and was excited to try it out. I thought the brand had a good reputation so the quality of the product would be as stated. Sadly it did not live up to the description.
Application was smooth, no stabby points which was nice. I managed to get nice thin lines but also used a makeup brush to smudge it out. It did look nice after being used.
However even after it had dried down like the instructions said to it still smudged alot. I was wearing this for my work day 9 hours and it looked like I had been out all night clubbing. It was the worst with the black shade. Didn't notice it so much with the bronze shade.
I will continue to use it until it's gone or expired, whichever comes first. I will not be repurchasing.
Let me start by saying that I love urban decay.. These are one of the few things that I don't like from their product line. The liners are smooth, creamy and pigmented BUT they will not stay on my eyes. My lids aren't excatly super oily or anything but these give me panda eyes by the end of the day. It sucks because they have some amazing shades.