I have 'naked' and 'f-bomb' and find them quite sheer compared to the lipsticks, wouldn't say they're super saturated when it comes to colour. But they are very smooth and creamy. They don't dry down so have a tendency to smudge easily. They almost feel like a lip balm rather than a colour, which is good as they keep lips hydrated. Gives a real shine. Doesn't last through eating or drinking, as you would expect from a 'wet' product.
Outside of the pencils basically match the colour of the product making it easy to choose. You do need a large sharpener for them.
When these got released, I was very skeptical of them. This was before a lot of the big liquid lipsticks brands had released their gems. These are amazing. They are stick, sharpenable lipsticks that have a beautiful built in gloss in them. The shades are amazing. I loved how they have a hot pink color and also a darker pink with glitter! A red with an orange base and a red with a blue base so it fits everyone! It uses plant ingredients which is so important to me as well. It has a really great lasting power which was shocking since it was so glossy! I only had to reapply once when using it on a 12+ hour work day. No lip liner needed. Just one stick to do it all is awesome. It is a very creamy formula and nothing about it is ever sticky which is awesome. The only downside to these are that they do transfer onto cups, cheeks, napkins etc. so they wouldn’t be a great choice for a dinner party or anything like that.