Vault

Max value reached

Adding this item would put you over your total vault limit of $250. please review your cart to stay under the limit.

Water based primer

20 posts, 7 members
LucyAnnexx
29 posts
Now I'm still a complete makeup rookie.. I hardly ever wear a full face because my skin reacts and I break out after. 

I recently heard something about mixing oil, silica and water based products ranging from your moisturiser, primer, foundation, powder and setting sprays. 

Generally oil and water don't mix well at all and it got my wondering about why I can't seem to get a smooth base. Turns out my moisturiser and foundations are water based and the primers i use are oil and silica based! I found this super interesting! 

Does anyone have top water based primers that they use?
Do you mix your oil, silica and water based products?
Has this inspired you to have a look at what base your makeup products have? 
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
Hi, as far as I know water based primers tend to be more hydrating whereas silicone ones are smoothing. Some good water ones are the Becca Backlight priming filter, Smashbox Primer Water and Too Faced Hangover. I have mixed the Hourglass mineral veil silicone primer with water based foundations with out issues but your right, it's best to avoid it. 
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
This topic has got me checking into everything I use and it's doing my head in hehe.

What foundations do you currently wear?
Silvene
1289 posts
I have very oily skin and prior to lockdown I was using Rimmel Stay Matte Primer and Rimmel Stay Matte Foundation.  I haven't worn make-up for 7 weeks, and my skin is looking fabulous! It's the longest I've ever gone without any make-up. 
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
There's always a silver lining huh :)
Even though I'm crazy about makeup I actually only wear it on the weekends regardless. Still wworking on getting the best primer foundation combo
Emily-jane
314 posts
Currently using a mixture of Osmosis BB cream and foundation and Nars tinted glow booster.  I have super fair skin so it's hard to find shades that suit. 
Macs
5360 posts
Honestly wouldn't have a clue what your talking about. Give me something to read about while I'm at work tommorow.
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
I ended going down an 'ingredients rabbit hole' working out whether my things are water or silicone based. I don't think moisturisers are too much of an issue. I did notice all of mine are water based so I'm guessing majority would be. It's hard cause you tend to buy a primer based on your skin concern ie pore filling, hydration, glowyness, mattyfying etc rather than focusing on whether it will mix with your foundation. Ive made a list of my products that are silicone or water based and I'm going to experiment on how much of a difference it makes when mixing them
Emily-jane
314 posts
So my original post cut off argh. Anyway my primer has silicone in it but my foundation etc doesn't. My bigger issue is how my sunscreen and primer mix together so this could explain why. Can anyone recommend a nice water based primer for drier skin? I'm keen to try this out.
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
good water based primers that I know of are Smashbox Primeriser, Too Faced hangover, Becca backlight and Dior face and body. Sorry these are higher price ones. There is a good Maybelline range for all typesthat could work ... Haven't tried though
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
Also you can get minis of the Primeriser and hangover at Mecca so good if you want to try it out like I often do :)

Oh and the Becca one is more glowy than it is hydrating, but it is waterbased 
trudijoy
8375 posts
i'm OBSESSED with hangover primer.  i even wear it on makeup-free days. 
Kat555
143 posts
Oh wow, I had never thought of that. Maybe that's why I have only ever tried primers and then not bothered because they didn't seem to improve anything much! Apparently I have a lot to learn!
Kat555
143 posts
I'm really fair too Emily-jane. What foundations do you find best? I really struggle.
Emily-jane
314 posts
Thanks Jackie. I will have a look at those, hopefully I can sample first.

Kat555 I 'm currently using Osmosis foundation and BB cream, they are a skincare brand too. They are pricey but they have a nice fair shade and doesn't break me out. 
Kat555
143 posts
Thanks so much Emily-jane I will have to look into that.
LucyAnnexx
29 posts
Thanks for all of your replies! 
I'm glad you found this as interesting as I did! I will definitely look into the water based primers you've all suggested :) 

I usually use smoothing primers but all of my other products are water based so it'll be interesting to try and see if it helps!
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
I'm not sure if this is true but in my research I saw someone wrote

"you can use silicone over water most of the time without issues but water over silicone will slide right off"

So yeah if your using water foundations then defo try water primer. I'll test the theory about water primer under silicone foundation as I have a few of each and I'm really curious
Kat555
143 posts
May be a silly question but how can you tell what sort your foundation is?
 
JackieMackenzie
341 posts
Not silly at all. Most foundations will show Aqua/water as the first ingredient regardless whether silicone or water based, but the following few ingredients are the teller. If they end in 'cone' such as Dimethicone and methicone, also Siloxane ... They all lead us to think it's silicone based. If it does have Dimethicone etc in the ingredients but it's listed much further down then it's probably not silicone based. Some are quite hard to decipher thou I've found. If I'm not sure I Google it and and work it out that way. 

WELCOME TO NZ'S BIGGEST BEAUTY GUIDE!

READ AND WRITE REVIEWS ON YOUR FAVOURITE (or not so favourite!) PRODUCTS!

Sign up to receive our newsletter and stay up to date with all of the latest happenings here at Beauty Review!

You'll be the first to know about Trial Teams, Vault restocks and Giveaways.

We promise never to spam you - only to share the best in NZ beauty!

CLICK HERE TO JOIN THE MAILING LIST!